e-agenda.NET

Exceptions Hearing re Gwen Johnson
May 27, 2009


Convene
1. 4:04 p.m.

Public Comments
2. None

Board Report(s)
3. Exceptions Hearing re: Gwen Johnson
Attachment: Exception Proceedings for Board_092508.pdf
Attachment: Recommended Order.pdf
Minutes: 

Mr. Ford requested a response from Board Members as to whether or not they have read the exceptions transcript and Mr. Williams objected that this was not an appropriate request of the Board. 

 

Mr. Ford presented the first finding of fact on behalf of Gwen Johnson and and Ms. Hill responded on behalf of the School District.

 

Motion to reject the first exception to a finding of fact by Benaim/Hill was approved 6/1 with Robinson dissenting.

 

Mr. Ford presented the second finding of fact and Ms. Hill responded.

 

Motion to reject the second exception to a finding of fact by Benaim/Burdick was approved 6/1 with Robinson dissenting.

 

Mr. Ford presented the third finding of fact and Ms. Hill responded.

 

Motion to accept the third exception to a finding of fact by Robinson died for lack of a second.

 

Motion to reject the third exception to a finding of fact by Benaim/Hill was approved 6/1 with Robinson dissenting.

 

Mr. Ford presented the fourth finding of fact and Ms. Hill responded.

 

Motion to reject the fourth exception to a finding of fact by Benaim/Hill was approved 6/1 with Robinson dissenting.

 

Mr. Ford presented the fifth finding of fact and Ms. Hill responded.

 

Motion by Benaim/Burdick to postpone the start of the Board Meeting until conclusion of this meeting was unanimously approved.

 

Motion to reject the fifth exception to a finding of fact by Robinson/Benaim was unanimously approved.

 

Mr. Ford presented the sixth finding of fact and Ms. Hill responded.

 

Motion to accept the sixth exception to a finding of fact by Robinson/Hill failed 3/4 with Benaim/Graham/Richmond/Burdick dissenting.

 

Motion to reject the sixth exception to a finding of fact by Benaim/Burdick was approved 4/3 with Barbieri/Hill/Robinson dissenting.

 

Mr. Ford presented the seventh finding of fact and Ms. Hill responded.

 

Motion to reject the seventh exception to a finding of fact by Benaim/Hill was approved 6/1 with Robinson dissenting.

 

Mr. Ford presented the eighth finding of fact and Ms. Hill responded.

 

Motion to reject the eighth exception to a finding of fact by Benaim/Burdick was approved 6/1 with Robinson dissenting.

 

Mr. Ford presented the ninth finding of fact and Ms. Hill responded.

 

Motion to reject the ninth exception to a finding of fact by Benaim/Burdick was approved 6/1 with Robinson dissenting.

 

Mr. Ford presented the tenth and eleventh finding of fact and Ms. Hill responded.

 

Motion to reject the tenth exception to a finding of fact by Robinson/Benaim was approved 6/1 with Robinson dissenting.

 

Motion to reject the eleventh exception to a finding of fact by Benaim/Hill was approved 6/1 with Robinson dissenting.

 

Motion by Benaim/Hill to instruct Chief Counsel to prepare Final Order except as modified upholding the 20 work day suspension was followed by discussion.

 

Amended Motion by Robinson to decrease the penalty to zero days suspension since she has already served many days at a decreased level of authority, failed for lack of a second.

 

Main Motion was approved 6/1 with Robinson dissenting.


Adjourn
4. 6:00 p.m.






Secretary

Chair